Natural Farm bully sticks are suitable for medium chewers, making them a good pick for most dogs. They’re also odor-free, so they won’t offend nearby humans.

Made from grass-fed, free-range Brazilian cattle, the pizzles used in these bully sticks have no hormones, additives, or chemicals. They’re single-ingredient and cleaned with water, then slowly oven-baked to preserve the nutrients.

Natural Farm bullies come in traditional sticks, as well as springs, rings, braids, and bites. Depending on the size and chewing style of your dog, you can choose from standard, select, jumbo, pixie, and extra-thin sticks. We think the standard 6-inch bully sticks are appropriate for most dogs’ chewing needs, and appreciate the flexible packaging on offer, with 12- and 16-ounce packs in addition to 15-, 20-, and 25-pizzle packages.

Natural Farm donates a portion of proceeds from every sale to organizations that help animals in need worldwide, and the packaging is made with 51 percent recyclable sugar cane.

_{Form: Sticks, springs, braids, bites, rings | Amount: 1.2 pounds | Breed Size: Small, medium, large}

Nature Gnaws Natural Dog Chews are braided bully sticks made entirely from grass-fed, free-range cattle. A braided bully stick is made of three strips of pizzle that are tightly braided together and then baked to form a dog treat.

Nature Gnaws’ bullies are made without additives, preservatives, or artificial ingredients. The bullies are cleaned with water and then baked in the oven.

The company relies on human-grade food testing to make sure the chews aren’t contaminated with bacteria. In addition to braids, Nature Gnaws sells extra-thin, small, large, and spring-shaped bullies.

_{Form: Braided | Amount: 5 count | Breed Size: Small, medium, large}

Barkworthies are single-ingredient chews with no artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors. The beef is sourced from South America. There is also a line of sticks baked in the U.S.

There are so many different styles for light, medium, hard, and even power chewers, ranging from standard, braided, and curly sticks to jumbo, double cut, and monster sticks. For light and medium chewers, there are also long and skinny cane sticks, which can be cut into smaller pieces.

_{Form: Sticks | Amount: 5 count | Breed Size: Small, medium, large}

These bully bones are made from grass-fed beef that is processed in a USDA human-grade certified and inspected facility. They are boiled, roasted, smoked, and slow-dried without any additives or chemicals.

The process keeps the treats fresh longer without preservatives and helps keep them odor-free. However, once pups start chewing, these sticks develop a very gamey smell.

The premium sticks are especially good for dogs to gnaw on to keep their teeth and gums healthy. The company makes bullies in standard, thick, and jumbo sizes, and they are available in six-inch or 12-inch lengths.

Jack & Pup also has bites, braids, and curls. Bites should only be given to the tiniest of dogs because their small size could be choking hazards for larger pets.

_{Form: Sticks | Amount: 1.17 pounds | Breed Size: Small, medium, large}

Smaller dogs, with smaller mouths and teeth to match, will enjoy chewing on Best Bully Sticks, which range in length from 2 to 4 inches. Within a pack, the thickness will vary among each treat, but all sticks are made in the United States from free-range, grass-fed beef.

Best Bully Sticks are suitable for dogs of any age, including teething puppies. They are moderately dense and should keep your dog occupied for an extended time.

_{Form: Sticks | Amount: 8 ounces | Breed Size: Small}

If you have several dogs or just feed your pup a lot of treats, it can be convenient and save you money to buy in bulk. Sancho & Lola offers that option for all its many forms of bully sticks. They’re all made without growth hormones, toxic chemicals, or antibiotics.

The charcuterie-style sticks are made from beef farmed in the United States, and other bully products from the brand are from free-range, grass-fed cattle farmed in North and South America. All of Sancho & Lola’s products are processed, inspected, and packed in facilities in Texas and Nebraska.

You can choose from traditional, thick, or crunchy in several different lengths. You can also opt for a range of smells from no odor to moderate odor. However, the moderate-odor treats are actually really stinky, which your dog will love more than you will. A portion of all proceeds goes to dog rescues.

_{Form: Sticks | Amount: 24-30 count | Breed Size: Small, medium, large}

These hard treats are made from 100 percent yak and cow’s milk with a little salt and lime juice for added taste. The chews have no gluten, grain, soy, lactose, or corn.

There are no artificial preservatives, colors, flavors, or additives. Dogs just chew and scrape until they can get little pieces off.

When the stick gets too small, you can soak it in water, microwave it, let it cool, and feed it to your pup as a special cheese puff treat. That way, nothing is wasted.

The treats come from the Himalayas, where they support a network of more than 10,000 farmers who handcraft them. They are certified Fair Trade by the World Fair Trade Organization. For every pound of cheese chewed, the company donates a book to a library in Nepal.

_{Form: Sticks | Amount: 1 count | Breed Size: Small, medium, large}

Each Bully Stick Party Pack from Redbarn offers an assortment of sticks made from 100 percent beef pizzle with no artificial preservatives or additives. The sticks are suitable as a treat for dogs of all life stages, from puppy to senior, and giving your dog a bully stick from the party pack will likely help to reduce buildup along their gum line.

The variety packs come in two sizes: a 12-ounce package with bully sticks ranging from 4 to 5 inches in length and an 8-ounce package with bully sticks measuring 5 to 8 inches long. Since these packs are sold by weight, the number of sticks in each bag often varies. The thickness of the sticks can also vary, with some pizzles being thinner than others.

_{Form: Sticks | Amount: 8 ounces, 12 ounces | Breed Size: Small, medium, large}

If your pup is bullish on bully sticks, Woof offers an economical way to keep you well-stocked on your pet’s favorite chews. With a direct-to-consumer model, the company provides high-quality bully sticks made from free-range and sustainably sourced grass-fed beef that are about 25 percent less expensive than other brands. You save even more with an auto-ship subscription.

Woof bully sticks come in 6-inch and 12-inch lengths and are available in packs of 5, 10, or 25. While we like that the sticks provide a long-lasting chew, we’re not fans of the smell, which is still detectable despite the company’s claim that the product is “low odor.” Nevertheless, if your dog loves the taste, then they’re definitely worth the savings.

Woof also offers a unique holder for a bully stick called the BullySafe, designed to hold the bully stick in place to extend the duration of play and reduce the risk of choking. This extra tool can be added to your order, and it’s easy to use—simply unscrew, insert the bully, tighten, and let your dog enjoy.

_{Form: Sticks | Amount: 5, 10, or 25 count | Breed Size: Small, medium, large}

These treats are made from 100% wolffish skins from wild-caught and sustainably sourced fish. The easily digestible treats are high in protein, making for a healthy and nutritious alternative to rawhide. Because fish skin is naturally packed with omega-3 fatty acids, these treats also help to promote healthy skin and coat.

That said, they do have a strong fishy smell, which may not appeal to all dogs. Also, they don’t provide as long a chew as rawhide, and the skin can get quite rubbery, which can pose a choking hazard.

The treats are available in two varieties—wolffish and cod—and come in 3.5-ounce and 5.5-ounce bags.

_{Form: Dehydrated treats | Amount: 3.5 ounces, 5.5 ounces | Breed Size: Small}

These bully sticks from Vital Essentials are made from 100 percent premium beef pizzle, responsibly sourced and made in the USA. Like the brand’s other single-protein treats, these are freeze-dried for a full 48 hours, preserving more of the essential nutrients. As a result, these are lighter in weight than traditional bully sticks and easier to chew, and they gently remove plaque buildup.

On the downside, this also means large dogs and aggressive chewers can quickly blow through a 1.4-ounce bag, which may at times contain only 3 sticks. While pet parents appreciate the high-quality ingredients and report their dogs love the taste, several take issue with the cost.

_{Form: Freeze-dried sticks | Amount: 1.4 ounces | Breed Size: All}

Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter, a popular recommendation of veterinarians and dog owners we surveyed, is our top choice for dogs. The human-grade recipe contains one ingredient, dry-roasted peanuts. There is no added oil, salt, or sugar in the all-natural recipe. Yet, customers praise the flavor, meaning it’s a safe pantry item to keep on hand for your entire family (humans and dogs included).

Dr. Lippman adds that while giving a product marketed “for dogs” can give you peace of mind, there’s actually less regulation around treats and even supplements, so sometimes she prefers giving “people stuff.” She continues, “I like giving them things that I know I would eat.” 

Teddie Peanut Butter has a smooth consistency and is easy to spread on lick mats or feed on a spoon. It’s not likely to get runny or separate either. This peanut butter comes in a 1-pound jar and is more affordable than some other options.

It is sold in a 1-pound, 10-ounce size and can be purchased in a pack of six. Teddie Peanut Butter also comes in a ‘Super Chunky’ variation with similar natural ingredients.

_{Primary Ingredients: Dry-roasted peanuts | Size/Volume: 16-ounce, 26-ounce jars}

Dilly’s Poochie Butter, which was formulated for dogs, has five simple ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, flaxseed, turmeric, parsley, and ginger. There’s no added sugar or salt in the human-grade recipe. 

“I and other vets recommend it because it contains natural nuts and coconut oil,” Dr. Dawn Filos, a veterinarian of over 30 years, shared with The Spruce Pets. “Ginger helps with settling stomachs, which, along with turmeric and cinnamon, is also anti-inflammatory. Parsley helps with dogs’ breath, and is said to help with urinary health and itch relief, as well as being loaded with vitamins A and C, folic acid, and antioxidants.” 

Dilly’s Poochie Butter comes in a 1-pound jar and has feeding recommendations for dogs weighing both under and over 25 pounds. 10 percent of all profits are donated to animal shelters and similar organizations, according to the brand.

_{Primary Ingredients: Dry-roasted peanuts, flaxseed, turmeric, parsley, ginger | Size/Volume: 16-ounce jar}

Whole Foods Market Peanut Butter comes in at a close second and is also recommended by Dr. Filos as a peanut butter that is safe for both dogs and humans. The simple recipe has one ingredient (USDA-certified organic dry-roasted peanuts) and is free of preservatives, salt, and sugar. It has a creamy texture and a real-peanut taste.

The 1-pound jar of this peanut butter comes in three variations: organic creamy, sweetened crunchy organic, and sweetened smooth organic. We recommend the Organic Creamy Peanut Butter for dogs because it is the simplest recipe. The other two variations include added salt, sugar, and oil, which should be avoided.  

_{Primary Ingredients: Organic dry-roasted peanuts | Size/Volume: 16-ounce jar}

Spread The Love NAKED Organic Peanut Butter has a one-ingredient recipe of organic peanuts. It has no added salt, sugar, or oil and is USDA-certified organic. 

The texture is ultra-creamy, which might get runny, but can be thickened by stirring and then storing the tub in the refrigerator. It can be spread on a lick mat or spoon for your dog and is a human-marketed product that your entire family could enjoy. This peanut butter is available in a 1-pound jar and can also be purchased in a pack of six. 

_{Primary Ingredients: Organic dry-roasted peanuts | Size/Volume: 16-ounce jar}

Dilly’s Poochie Butter is the best dog brand, but Bark Bistro Buddy Budder is a great alternative because of its unique flavor options. While each one has a slightly different recipe, they all have a peanut base and are free of artificial sugar, salt, hydrogenated oils, xylitol, and alcohol. The Pumpkin Pup, for example, contains pumpkin, cinnamon, and honey in addition to peanuts.

This wide variety of flavors means you can choose a peanut butter with added ingredients you know will appeal to your dog, ensuring they will consider it a high-value treat. Our favorite—‘Begging Bacon’—contains peanuts, bacon, and honey. Although this peanut butter has a runny texture, it will thicken when stored in the refrigerator.

_{Primary Ingredients: Peanuts, apple, cinnamon, honey (Awesome Apple); peanuts, banana, strawberry, honey (Banana Split); peanuts, bacon, honey (Beggin Bacon); peanuts, carob, vanilla, honey (Brownie Batter); peanuts, pineapple, carrot, honey (Carrot Cake); peanuts, strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, honey (Superberry Snoot); peanuts, pumpkin, cinnamon, honey (Pumpkin Pup) | Size/Volume: 17-ounce jar}

The WholeHearted Loveable Lickables Peanut Butter Dog Treats are packaged in a squeezable tube that can be easily taken on the go. It has been specifically formulated for dogs, similar to our other recommendations, and has a simple recipe. In addition to peanuts, oatmeal and pumpkin add healthy fiber to this recipe.

“I really do like the easy use of this, especially when dispensing it into Kong toys, which can be hard to fill with a spoon or knife,” says Dr. Filos. “The pumpkin also makes the peanut butter softer and easier to dispense from a squirt tube.”

This peanut butter can be purchased in 2-ounce or 8-ounce tubes or in packs of 6. The brand recommends refrigerating it for a creamy texture and massaging the tube to soften it so it’s more spreadable. 

_{Primary Ingredients: Peanuts, oatmeal, pumpkin | Size/Volume: 2-ounce, 8-ounce tube}

The PBfit Powdered Peanut Powder is our top recommendation for a peanut butter in powder form. You add water to thicken it to your desired consistency, giving you more control over the texture. Made of peanut flour, PBfit is formulated for humans and has a simple dog-safe recipe.

This powder comes in a 1-pound, 8-ounce jar, which is slightly bigger than most of the options on our list. In addition to using the PBfit Powdered Peanut Powder as a treat for your dog, it can also be added to smoothies and yogurt. 

_{Primary Ingredients: Peanut flour | Size/Volume: 24-ounce jar}

Bocce’s Bakery is known for simple recipes and natural ingredients made in small batches. These Soft & Chewy treats in Peanut Butter & Banana are the best peanut butter treats for dogs. They are oven-baked and have a simple nine-ingredient recipe that includes peanut butter, rolled oats, flaxseed, banana, and carob chips. 

The Bocce’s Bakery Soft & Chewy Peanut Butter & Banana Recipe is sold in a 6-ounce resealable bag. Each treat contains 14 calories per treat but has a crumbly texture that makes it easy to break into smaller pieces to reward your dog.

The softness of these chews makes them good to give to senior dogs as well. These treats come in four other standard recipes, and Bocce’s Bakery also tends to release seasonal flavors.  

_{Primary Ingredients: Oat Flour, peanut butter, coconut glycerin, rolled oats, cane molasses, flaxseed, banana, carob chips, citric acid | Size/Volume: 6-ounce bag}

After testing 25 dog chewers and comparing Benebone to Nylabone, we recommend the Benebone Peanut Butter Flavor Wishbone Tough Dog Chew Toy. While it is made of nylon, which should not be ingested, it’s a great option for pet parents looking to satisfy their dog’s urge to chew. It has been infused with real peanuts, giving it a taste that will keep your dog engaged. 

The Wishbone Tough Dog Chew comes in four sizes: small, medium, large, and giant. It is shaped like a wishbone, and this ergonomic design makes it easy for dogs to hold on their own. It is dense, but not too heavy for dogs to maneuver. The Wishbone Tough Dog Chew Toy is available in bacon and chicken variations as well, which have also been infused with real flavors. 

_{Primary Ingredients: Peanuts | Size/Volume: Tiny, small, medium, large, giant}

Designed to work in tandem with the Woof Pupsicle—a treat dispenser we tested and liked for lickable treats—these peanut butter-based pops are a mess-free alternative to the DIY versions made in silicone pop molds. They come ready to use; no need to freeze or refrigerate them to set. Each pop can last up to 40 minutes of playtime.

Although the ingredient list is longer than most of the other options here, they are all wholesome, human-grade, and none you can’t pronounce; there’s also no salt, sugar, or xylitol. Plus, they’re made without wheat or corn.

The Woof Pupsicle Refill pops come in three flavors—beef, birthday cake, and chicken—and three sizes. Each pop is 85.6 calories.

_{Primary Ingredients: Peanut butter (roasted peanuts), tapioca starch, chicken plasma, beef tallow, vegetable glycerin, date syrup, soy lecithin, brewers dried yeast, beef gelatin, blueberry | Size/Volume: Small (10 count), small (20 count), large (10 count), large (20 count), x-large (10 count), x-large (20 count)}